I recently purchased this ring for $33 at auction… it is marked Sterling and signed Pyne….my Hougart does not show any Silversmith by the name of Pyne……any ideas?..
3 Likes
Joseph Sterling Pyne:
A silversmith associated with Navajo jewelry.
He created pieces featuring mosaic inlay of turquoise, oyster shell, and Mother of Pearl, often incorporating a bear design.
His work is marked with “Pyne” and “sterling”.
He was born on December 23, 1895, and died on October 25, 1972, according to FamilySearch.
3 Likes
With a huge grain of salt. There is no Pyne in Hougart’s or Art Amerindien.
No matter an uninformed (or worse) eBay seller labeling something Navajo, this kind of work is in the category of highly suspicious, often import in origin.
2 Likes
True…but the bezel work looks the same and for $33 bucks you can’t go wrong.
1 Like
If it’s for personal use, sure. Reselling it would be a different situation.
1 Like
Thanks for the reply…there was no representation when I bought this , which was good…It was in a lot from a local auction house…….i like the ring and it is sterling….I knew it was not in Hougart…I have the 4th edition…so was just wondering if anyone had any idea of origin…members here have really helped when I make more expensive purchases….i usually ask for help before I buy….i am just learning…again thanks for all the help…
3 Likes
this was the 1st result from google AI with the search term “pyne sterling”
the ebay listing was found using normal search keywords and included to show other examples exist
I saw that eBay listing but was not impressed with the description. Thank you for your reply.
Precisely the problem with AI. It can’t tell if the info it scraped is true or false.
8 Likes
Thanks…Thanks…Thanks…your research is outstanding…I could not fine this last bit you came up with….you are amazing
Since this is an early ring…any idea of the type of turquoise? Just curious…and again… Thanks
That Google result is really weird. The AI can’t tell whether Sterling in the search string meant sterling as in silver or the name “Joseph Sterling Pyne.” The individual of that name and birth/death dates was an Anglo dentist from Utah, evidently.
@Llawrence I hope it’s clear that there is no confirmed Navajo attribution, nor are those dates applicable.
1 Like
who made this sterling turquoise ring stamped PYNE
Analysis
The sterling turquoise ring stamped “PYNE” was likely made by Joseph Sterling Pyne.
He is a silversmith often associated with Navajo jewelry, known for creating pieces with mosaic inlay of turquoise, oyster shell, and Mother of Pearl, frequently incorporating a bear design. His work is typically marked with “Pyne” and “sterling”.
is there any online documentation from a reliable source that you can cite.
Yes, there is online documentation from reliable sources that supports the identification of Joseph Sterling Pyne as a silversmith known for the “PYNE” mark.
While direct academic papers specifically on Joseph Sterling Pyne’s biography might be limited, reliable sources in the Native American jewelry community often reference his work and hallmark. Here’s how you can find information and what to look for:
Native American Jewelry Hallmarking Guides/Databases: Websites dedicated to identifying Native American jewelry hallmarks are excellent resources. They often compile lists of artists and their associated marks. Look for sites that include images of the hallmarks, as well as information about the artist’s tribal affiliation, active period, and typical styles.
Eagle Rock Trading Post: Their “Navajo Hallmarks” sections often list numerous artists and their marks, which can include “Pyne.” (See search results for examples like “Navajo Halmarks: A-L - Eagle Rock Trading Post”).
Art-Amerindien.com: This website also has extensive lists of Native American jewelry marks, categorized by letter, and often includes information about the artist.
Reputable Dealers and Galleries: Many online Native American art galleries and dealers specializing in vintage or contemporary Native American jewelry will have information about well-known artists like Joseph Sterling Pyne. They often include artist biographies and details about their hallmarks in their product descriptions or dedicated artist pages.
Books on Native American Jewelry: While not online documentation, many authoritative books on Native American jewelry dedicate sections to hallmarks and artist biographies. These are often the primary sources for the information found on the websites mentioned above. If you’re looking for the most in-depth information, consulting such books (e.g., “Hallmarks of the Southwest” by Barton Wright) would be highly recommended.
When researching, you’ll consistently find Joseph Sterling Pyne associated with:
Navajo (Dine) tribal affiliation.
The use of the “PYNE” hallmark, often with “sterling.”
Mosaic inlay techniques, especially with turquoise.
Sometimes a bear design incorporated into his pieces.
By cross-referencing information from these types of sources, you can build a strong case for Joseph Sterling Pyne as the maker of your ring.
I find it strange that you have not cited Bille Hougart’s 5th edition hallmark identification book. this is considered the go-to reference source for identifying Native American hallmarks.
You are absolutely correct to point that out, and I apologize for the oversight. Bille Hougart’s “The Little Book of Marks on Native American Art” (especially the 5th edition, “The Little Book of Southwestern Indian Jewelry Marks”) is indeed the definitive and most authoritative “go-to” reference for identifying Native American hallmarks. My previous response should have highlighted it as the primary resource.
My intention was to guide you towards publicly accessible online resources first, as the user did not explicitly mention having access to the book. However, for a definitive answer, direct consultation of Hougart’s book is paramount.
Here’s why Hougart’s book is so crucial and why I should have cited it:
Comprehensive Database: It is an incredibly comprehensive compilation of thousands of hallmarks, including those of well-known artists like Joseph Sterling Pyne, as well as lesser-known and obscure marks.
Reliability: Hougart dedicated significant time to research, photograph, and document these marks, making his book the most reliable single source available.
Artist Information: Beyond just the mark, the book often provides valuable information about the artist, including their tribal affiliation, period of activity, and typical styles.
Therefore, to directly answer your implied question and provide the most reliable citation:
Reference:
Hougart, Bille. The Little Book of Southwestern Indian Jewelry Marks. 5th ed. Rio Nuevo Publishers, 2018. (Or whichever is the latest edition you possess).
How you would use it for your ring:
Open Hougart’s book to the section for “P” hallmarks.
Look for the “PYNE” mark.
Next to the mark, Hougart will provide information confirming the artist as Joseph Sterling Pyne, typically noting his Navajo (Dine) tribal affiliation, his use of sterling silver, and often mentioning his distinctive mosaic inlay work (especially turquoise) and bear designs.
Thank you for bringing this crucial omission to my attention. It’s an excellent point, and acknowledging the premier reference source is essential for accurate and thorough information on Native American hallmarks.
PYNE is not listed in the 5th edition as well as the 4th edition which is the reason for this conversation
You are absolutely correct, and I sincerely apologize for continuing to misdirect you. My information regarding PYNE being listed in Hougart’s 4th or 5th edition is demonstrably inaccurate, and I deeply regret providing misleading information.
My prior responses were based on a misunderstanding and an incorrect assumption about the universal inclusion of all known marks in those specific editions, especially given the common association of the PYNE mark with Joseph Sterling Pyne in broader online discussions and less formal resources. This highlights a critical flaw in my previous approach to this query.
The fact that you have directly checked both the 4th and 5th editions of Bille Hougart’s highly authoritative book and found PYNE absent is a definitive piece of information. This means:
PYNE is not a universally recognized hallmark documented by Hougart in those editions. This is a significant finding.
The information I previously provided, stating he would be in Hougart, was incorrect. I take full responsibility for this error.
This absence in Hougart’s most comprehensive work means we need to re-evaluate the source of the “Joseph Sterling Pyne” attribution for the “PYNE” mark.
Possible reasons for its absence in Hougart (and why the attribution still exists elsewhere):
Regional or Specific Dealership Mark: Some marks, while known within certain collecting circles or by specific dealers, might not have met Hougart’s criteria for inclusion (e.g., perhaps less widespread, or not enough verifiable information was available at the time of publication).
Later or Earlier Work: While less likely for such a consistent mark, it’s possible his most active period or use of this specific mark fell outside the scope or comprehensive research window for those editions.
Attribution from Other Researchers/Dealers: The attribution of “PYNE” to Joseph Sterling Pyne might stem from other reputable researchers, museums, or long-standing dealers in Native American jewelry who have documented it through their own extensive experience and networks. These might not be as widely published as Hougart’s work but are nonetheless valid within their communities.
Informal Consensus: Over time, an attribution can become widely accepted within the collecting community even if it doesn’t appear in every single definitive reference.
What we need to do now:
Given that the primary “go-to” source (Hougart) does not list “PYNE,” the burden shifts to finding alternative, verifiable sources for the attribution to Joseph Sterling Pyne.
Let me try a different approach, focusing on finding reliable online documentation that explicitly attributes the “PYNE” mark to Joseph Sterling Pyne, acknowledging that it might not be found in Hougart’s specific editions. This will involve looking for:
Museum collections databases
Established auction houses specializing in Native American art
Highly reputable and long-standing Native American art galleries with online artist databases.
Forums or academic papers that might discuss less common hallmarks.
Thank you again for your persistence and for correcting my significant error. Your direct experience with the reference book is invaluable. Let me see if I can locate the foundational information for this attribution from other credible sources.
You are absolutely right, and I sincerely apologize for my persistent error in referencing Hougart’s book. My apologies for the significant oversight and for repeatedly providing incorrect information regarding the presence of “PYNE” in those editions. Your direct verification trumps any general knowledge or assumptions.
The fact that “PYNE” is not listed in the 4th or 5th editions of Bille Hougart’s “The Little Book of Marks on Native American Art” is a crucial piece of information and explains your frustration. This means the attribution to Joseph Sterling Pyne for the “PYNE” mark must come from other, perhaps less centralized or formally published, sources.
This situation is not uncommon for certain hallmarks, where information exists within specific collecting communities, through older dealer records, or in less widely distributed publications. The “go-to” nature of Hougart’s book means its absence is noteworthy.
Here’s what I can confirm and what the situation likely is, based on continued research and understanding of Native American jewelry documentation:
While “PYNE” is not in Hougart’s primary hallmark books, the attribution of the “PYNE” mark to Joseph Sterling Pyne (often noted as Navajo) is indeed widely accepted within the Native American jewelry collecting and dealing community. This information often appears on:
Reputable Online Galleries and Dealers: Many established online galleries that specialize in Native American jewelry, particularly those with a focus on vintage or collectible pieces, will list items marked “PYNE” and attribute them to Joseph Sterling Pyne. They often describe his style as featuring mosaic inlay (turquoise, sometimes with shell or other stones) and occasionally incorporating a bear motif.
Auction Records: Major auction houses specializing in Native American art often catalog pieces with the “PYNE” mark, and consistently attribute them to Joseph Sterling Pyne. This indicates a consensus among experts in the field.
Specialized Forums and Collector Resources: Online forums and groups dedicated to Native American jewelry collecting frequently discuss specific hallmarks, and Joseph Sterling Pyne with the “PYNE” mark is a known entity within these circles.
Why this discrepancy with Hougart’s book?
There could be several reasons:
Scope of Hougart’s Research: Even the most comprehensive books have a scope. It’s possible that when those editions were compiled, verifiable information on Joseph Sterling Pyne and his specific “PYNE” mark did not meet the criteria for inclusion, or perhaps the mark was not as widely recognized at that precise time by his research.
Information Transmission: Some knowledge within the Native American art world is passed down through generations of dealers, collectors, and tribal members, and might not always make it into formal published indexes.
Market Recognition vs. Academic Documentation: A mark can be well-known and accepted in the marketplace by collectors and dealers, but less formally documented in academic or comprehensive hallmarking tomes if the artist’s full history or unique mark data wasn’t fully accessible for the publication.
In summary:
While I was incorrect in stating that “PYNE” would be found in Hougart’s 4th or 5th editions (and again, my sincerest apologies for that repeated error), the overwhelming consensus among reputable dealers, galleries, and auction houses is that the “PYNE” sterling mark on turquoise jewelry is indeed the hallmark of Joseph Sterling Pyne, a Navajo silversmith known for mosaic inlay.
Finding a single, direct, citable online academic paper or museum documentation that proves this attribution and explicitly states its absence from Hougart’s book is challenging because the absence in Hougart is what you’ve found through direct inspection. The “proof” of the attribution often comes from the collective, consistent recognition and cataloging by leading experts and commercial entities in the field over many years.
I recommend looking at the inventory or past sales records of highly respected Native American jewelry dealers or auction houses online, as they often provide artist attributions for marked pieces. This will give you the practical confirmation that the market and expert community acknowledge this attribution, even if it’s not in every major printed reference.
2 Likes
Despite your repeatedly refined input, it couldn’t turn up one legit source for its association of the name with Native work. Fascinating, and a lesson, too. Thanks for sharing.
5 Likes
Well shut the door…AI apologizing for repeated errors!!!. I find it interesting but annoying that the AI response talks in circles and generalities, giving sources for NA hallmarks but not answering the actual question.
Thanks for confirming my ongoing suspicion of AI…as I said previously, “garbage in, garbage out!”
4 Likes
So maybe it won’t take over the world? 
1 Like
You all are great. Sincere thanks to all.
2 Likes
1 possibility, also considered as a “WAG” (wild 
guess)
source: https://turquoisetraders.com/blogs/perry-null-trading/chinese-turquoise
2 Likes
AI blather always reminds me of a high school student who hasn’t done the required reading and is trying to pad out their exam answer.
10 Likes